Tuesday, March 6, 2012

To capture a mood: Mania


Mental Illness. It’s always been here. It always will be. Why are we still afraid to talk about it?

Perhaps this is a lofty goal for my simple blog, but I hope to raise awareness of mental illness and increase understanding.

I don’t claim to be an artist but I have made some collages and I think they’re pretty neat. First, I will tell you a bit about my “process.” I am always scanning printed materials for images that strike me. Usually I cannot readily explain why a particular image touches me, but if I feel something when I look at it I cut it out and tuck it away for later. I always have a shoebox of clippings in my closet.

Then, when I feel inspired, I empty my box and attempt to create a mood. My hope is, that when one looks at the collage, they are made to feel the mood I was attempting to capture. I do not claim success. Until now the only people who have seen my collages have been my husband and my sister, and I know they would tell me they’re great no matter what. So I must admit I feel quite exposed and vulnerable posting them on the internet. I’d like to reiterate that I do not label my collages as “art.” Rather, the process of making them is a therapeutic activity for myself.

Okay, enough preamble. Here is “Manic.”


Manic 2011/2012


As you may have guessed from the title, I was trying to capture the feeling of being trapped in a manic episode. Physicians use the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) to diagnose mental illness. I will be quoting from the Text-Revised Fourth Edition (2000, American Psychiatric Association).


The DSM criteria for diagnosis of a manic episode is as follows:


A) A distinct period of abnormally and persistently elevated, expansive or irritable mood, lasting at least 1 week (or any duration if hospitalization is necessary)


B) During the period of mood disturbance, three (or more) of the following symptoms have persisted (four if the mood is only irritable) and have been present to a significant degree:

1) inflated self-esteem or grandiosity
2) decreased need for sleep (e.g., feels rested after only 3 hours of sleep)
3) more talkative than usual or pressure to keep talking
4) flight of ideas or subjective experience that thoughts are racing
5) distractibility (i.e., attention too easily drawn to unimportant or irrelevant external stimuli)
6) increase in goal-directed activity (at work, at school, or sexually) or psychomotor agitation
7) excessive involvement in pleasurable activities that have a high potential for painful consequences (e.g., engaging in unrestrained buying sprees, sexual indiscretions, or foolish business investments)

C) The symptoms do not meet criteria for a Mixed Episode

D) The mood disturbance is sufficiently severe to cause marked impairment in occupational functioning or in usual social activities or relationships with others, or to necessitate hospitalization to prevent harm to self or others, or there are psychotic features.

E) The symptoms are not due to the direct physiological effects of a substance (e.g., a drug of abuse, a medication or other treatment) or a general medical condition (e.g., hyperthyroidism)

Note: Manic-like episodes that are clearly caused by somatic antidepressant treatment (e.g., medication, electroconvulsive therapy, light therapy) should not count toward a diagnosis of Bipolar I disorder.

Let's focus on the seven symptoms listed in criterion B, keeping in mind that all of them need not be present for the diagnosis of a manic episode.   I will use photos of different parts of the collage to discuss each symptom.

1) "inflated self-esteem or grandiosity"


The woman with the cigarette- doesn't she ooze confidence? When manic one may feel as if he or she is the most interesting and attractive person around. As you may guess, it feels good. However, this inflated sense of self-worth can be dangerous. One may feel invincible and take unnecessary risks. Grandiose delusions may develop. One may alienate oneself from his or her social network. 

In the manic state it feels as if anything is possible. Nothing is unreachable because you are so awesome and capable. The text here reads "NOT HOW OR WHEN OR WHY BUT YES." I want it and it will happen because I'm great.

Next symptom:

2) "decreased need for sleep"

This one is self-explanatory but very important because it is an objective measure. Diagnosing mental illness is extremely difficult because it is so subjective and often relies on the self-report of the individual, which may be unreliable. Exploring sleep patterns is therefore very useful in the diagnostic process. 

This image illustrates the next three symptoms I will discuss. 



Mania doesn't always feel good. You can feel threatened by your own thoughts. They come too fast and too hard and there is no respite. 

3) "more talkative than usual or pressure to keep talking"

Interacting with someone in the throes of mania is exhausting. They never shut up. They talk too fast. They don't make sense. The "pressure to keep talking" is a little more difficult to understand. A manic person may KNOW they are talking too much but feel incapable of stopping. When quiet a feeling of inner tension rises, only to be relieved when talking again. 

4) "flight of ideas or subjective experience that thoughts are racing"
5) "distractibility" 

As an observer you see a person jump from one topic to another, as a sufferer you feel out of control. 

Next symptom:
6) "increase in goal-directed activity or psychomotor agitation"


Mania can be a time of great productivity. Sleeping less leaves more time for action and increased self-esteem results in more ambitious goals. Of course there may be positive consequences of such behavior, but more often one takes on more than one can manage, resulting in feelings of defeat, failure and regret when the mania passes. 

Similar to the "pressure to keep talking" one may feel pressure to keep moving (psychomotor agitation). Examples include: pacing, fidgeting and picking at one's skin or nails. It is unpleasant. You wish you could sit still.

And now the final symptom listed in the DSM:

7) "excessive involvement in pleasurable activities that have a high potential for painful consequences" 


Most prominently featured in my collage are unsafe/impulsive/promiscuous sex and substance abuse. Others include excessive spending and impulsive investments. 

Mania is a very dangerous condition, complicated by the fact that it often feels good (at least at first). Despite severe and painful consequences from a manic episode a person with bipolar disorder may long for the feeling of happy confidence experienced while manic. This longing may lead to medication noncompliance, which then causes additional manic episodes, resulting in more damage to one's life and the lives of others. I therefore urge you to screen for mania in the people around you. I am NOT asking you to diagnose anyone, simply be aware of the symptoms and seek help if you believe someone is ill. 

And finally, talk about mental illness. I don't want it to be a secret anymore. People need help and they will not receive it if they are shamed and hidden. 

Later I will post photos of more of my collages to illustrate other forms of mental illness. In the meantime I would love to hear your thoughts and questions. I hope that you have never experienced mania yourself, but if you have suffered know that you are not alone. 

Spread the word!

Thank you for reading!

11 comments:

  1. I'm totally down with your efforts to combat the stigma behind mental illness. I hate that it's still awkward to talk about taking things as simple as anti-depressants, yet no one is ashamed to admit they need, say, allergy medication.

    Making collages is a neat idea, I haven't done that since like the 3rd grade. I have a sudden urge to make one though.

    I am prescribed adderall but it sometimes makes me quite manic. Of course this wouldn't meet the DSM standard since my mania would be drug-induced. Nevertheless, I can still very much relate to a lot of the symptoms you described.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right on with the allergy medication analogy.

      And I don't take adderall but coffee can put me in that manic state for a short period of time, so I can also totally relate. It can be fun sometimes, but also feel out of control and scary. Being trapped like that with no control over coming out of it or knowledge of when you might come down would be very frightening and dangerous.

      Delete
    2. Thank you both for sharing. Drug/caffeine-induced mania can be just as unpleasant as endogenous mania, and I'm glad you shared your experiences.

      And I love the allergy medication analogy. I have worked as a mental health and substance abuse counselor and would often use a similar analogy when one of my clients was ambivalent about taking medications. Sadly, sometimes the uninformed think that you can "will yourself" out of depression. However, if someone suggested that you lower your blood-pressure by willpower alone we would laugh. Mental illness is not a lack of willpower or weakness of character but rather a serious disease such as hypertension and allergies, and medication should be viewed as a valid option for treatment.

      I would like to add that I am NOT saying that everyone with mental health struggles should be on medication. There are other methods for altering one's brain chemistry (e.g. exercise, diet). Mental illness is an illness like any other, and therefore medications should be considered a valid treatment option, rather than as an indicator of personal "failure" to regulate one's mood.

      Delete
  2. Beautiful collage- really captures the mood. And great job piecing it apart to explain mania.

    It is curious/astounding/outrageous that mental illness is still such a taboo issue.Medicine is so prominent in today's society, but mental illness, which encompasses a huge percentage of the population, is absent from this arena. The media is full of stories about cancer, heart disease and other illnesses, even gluten intolerance! with stories of personal struggles and triumphs or research on new treatments. Even more impressive is the public's enthusiasm and power in support for huge awareness efforts and fundraisers for foundations that are dedicated entirely to supporting patients and finding cures for these diseases (Livestrong, Susan G Komen, the American Hearth Association...). Yet absent from all of these arenas is the issue of mental health- which I would guess afflicts just as many people. Those with mental illness are left to suffer on their own, silently or in secret. Think about it: waiting rooms for psychiatrists and psychologists are treated as anonymous lairs where there is no receptionist and patients are not meant to acknowledge or interact with each other. The doctors hide behind their doors like they are touting an illegal profession and the feds may walk in at any moment to bust them and their insane clients- they are often located behind closed doors in office suites rather than medical complexes or hospitals, and there are intentionally no identifying features on the door or in the office to link it with mental health treatment- can you think of an unhealthier way to treat the disease?

    The only mention of mental illness in the media is in cymbalta etc. ads, pumped into anonymous livingrooms across the country to catch the attention of those that are silently suffering. Occasionally a random psychopath like the unibomber makes the news. Its no wonder that society thinks of mental illness as scary and crazy because they are 'protected' from any acknowledgement of the hordes that suffer from mental illnesses like depression, bipolar, ocds, eating disorders, anxiety disorders, schizophrenia etc- the hordes of their neighbors, friends, coworkers, and even themselves. The guy in the cubicle next to you that is always very reserved and sullen... you don't know that he is struggling with debilitating depression, and he has no one to confide in. If he was a cancer survivor, on the other hand, he would surely be known around the office for his bravery and strength, and be strongly supported by his coworkers. If he was gluten intolerant he might get some weird looks, but this would still be acceptable to acknowledge and talk about...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right on sweiman. There are so many people suffering silently, or being silently judged. Before the advent of psychotropic drugs we tucked sufferers away in institutions. Now we are attempting to integrate back into society those whose symptom's can be safely managed through medication. Usually they enter a social network that is unsupportive of ongoing psychiatric treatment and it's no wonder they relapse and often return to the hospital. This cycle repeats again and again, incurring huge personal and societal costs. I believe increasing awareness of these silent sufferers is an important step in breaking this cycle.

      Thank you so much for painting the picture that you have. Your words are powerful and I agree with you 500% !!!

      Delete
  3. ...There are thousands of silent sufferers all around us, each suffering alone, unable to connect with each other over their struggles and debilitating disease because it is a taboo issue. Having the understanding and support from those who are suffering with the same symptoms and struggles is essential to healthy coping- to voice your frustrations, emotions and share coping mechanisms is critical to managing the disease, particularly when treatments are often incomplete or even ineffective, and the condition is a life long struggle. Because of the taboo, people who do not suffer with mental illness are unaware of how many around them are struggling, and are completely out of touch with what the REALITY of the disease is, familiar only with visions of psychopaths in slasher movies.The only time mental illness is recognized in the media is when someone goes so far off the deep end after years and years of suffering along in silence that they strike out and do something drastic and desperate, like commit suicide (which in and of itself is often hush hushed as well), or going on a shooting spree. these are rare exceptions to the daily suffering endured by thousands with mental illness who deserve and need each other's and society's support and understanding.

    Mental illness can be just as debilitating, if not more so, than other diseases like heart disease, cancer and diabetes. Holding down normal job may be extremely difficult if not impossible. And you know what comes with a job... health insurance. Mental illness is extremely costly, often requiring lifelong drug regimens and doctor's visits. Without health insurance, the mentally ill have 2 options: 1) don't get treatment and sink even further into your disease, OR 2) pay for your own health care (with no job for income) and go broke. Is it any coincidence that such a large proportion of homeless people are mentally ill? No, its not. If someone went jobless or homeless because they got cancer, it would be an outrage.

    We have much less understanding of mental illness than we do of cancer, diabetes, heart disease and nearly any other affliction. Treatments are often incomplete or even useless, leaving patients struggling with little or no hope in an endless and often losing battle against their disease. Maybe its time that we dedicate the enthusiasm, support and resources towards mental illness that we do towards all other areas of medicine. People with mental illness deserve just as much of our thoughts, prayers, voices, efforts and most of all, compassion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You make excellent points and it's no surprise to me that again I find myself exclaiming "yes!" and "right on!" and "I agree!" and "thank you!" Any interest in being a guest blogger?

      Thankfully, individuals with mental illness are covered under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Do people with mental illness know this? Most do not. Like you said, mental illness can be extremely debilitating. We need to explore how the ADA can help people structure their lives in ways that help them manage their illnesses. For example, an employer could help someone with bipolar disorder by giving them only daytime, predictable work schedules. We need to help people advocate for themselves, which many choose not to do because of the stigma attached to mental illness.

      Don't even get me started on health insurance issues . . .

      Delete
  4. Your comment "Its always been here." is interesting because yes, we openly acknowledge that mental illness existed historically and played an important part in a lot of beautiful, inspiring and innovative art. However, it is also misrepresented here. In the historical context it is almost glorified as we focus on the positive endproduct of a life that was most certainly wrought with the internal and external turmoils of mental illness. We overlook the day to day struggle and torment that the artist suffered. If we are to recognize mental illness, we must acknowledge all of it, the good and the bad, the mania and the depression and everything in between. We must recognize the person behind the disease.

    Also, in this case we recognize a select few that were able to channel their mental illness positively into therapeutic art, but what about the others, that bore their burden silently and alone, crushed under their disease and societies ignorance of it?

    Andy yet, why are we able to recognize mental illness openly in the past but not in the present? This seems backwards. Maybe because if it is in the past it is over- it no longer has to be dealt with and can no longer do harm. In the present, mental illness is much more frightening. What can and should we do about it? And even more frightening, what can it do to us, either as sufferers of the disease or as 'innocent bystanders victim to the insane actions of the mentally ill'? It feels much safer to deny that it even exists and refuse that there are any current threats. Mental Illness is like the inquisition- horrible and devastating, but in the past and no longer a danger to us. Nevermind current religious atrocities- we ignore those too, because its not our child being molested by a priest, right? or is it??? Ignorance is bliss, at least for those who don't have to face it head on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am happy you brought up artists that have posthumously received mental health diagnoses. Someone may say, "Hey look! There are brilliant people with mental illness who have accomplished great things!" I think these comments are made with good intentions, such as to make someone feel less alone or more optimistic. In some cases it is helpful. However, others may hear these comments and feel defeat/failure/despair/etc. because they have been unable to channel their illness into something admired by others. One should "embrace" one's diagnosis without feeling as if he/she needs to achieve greatness similar to the exceptional few who are romanticized.

      Delete
  5. Interestingly, ALL of my blogposts got deleted at first and I had to completely rewrite them, so painful. Even the internet was trying to silence discussion about mental illness. NO!! I WILL NOT ALLOW IT!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am so sorry that happened and I cannot thank you enough for taking the time and energy to write, and then rewrite your comments. You have made so many excellent points and I really hope people read your comments! Clearly, you are incredibly knowledgeable about mental illness and I'm honored that you have brought up so many issues, and provided examples that help people see/imagine the "silent suffering" around us. Thank you.

      Also, the last two sentences of this comment cracked me up :)
      Hey world-- you can't silence us!!

      Delete